The Internets have spoken, apparently Terminator was a horibble movie that will kill the franchise. The best proof of its horrible reception is the abysmal score it got on Rotten Tomatoes.
For full disclosure, I will enjoy any and every movie set in a post-apocolpytic future. You make a High School Musical: 2038 set in a post-nuke Chicago and I’ll see you there opening day. I came out of the theater quite happy with the final product. (Compared to leaving Wolverine in a state of depression). Why did I enjoy it?
(May contain spoilers). Let’s start off with the first complaint, John Conner is a nobody. In his first scene the commanding officer is telling him he isn’t in charge of the mission, a rebuke that Conner has likely heard many time before. If this man isn’t even in charge of the opening mission, then why, many critics have asked, are the machines trying to kill him? For starters, let’s look at the other movies.
In T2 Sarah Conner fell victim to the Cassandra effect as she tried in vain to warm humanity of its downfall. In the third movie John’s ultimate revelation is that there was never anything he could do to stop it. Judgment Day was inevitable. As so was his own place in it, though even he didn’t know how he would some how end up the leader of the resistance. At the end of the third movie, Connor ends up in a presidential bunker, helpless as the bombs begin to drop. As people on the receiving end of the communications line in the bunker call out asking what is happening, John does not have to convince them of a future apocalypse. He is the one and only person who is able to tell humanity what is happening.
When the bombs stop, was John Connor supposed to just suddenly be the instant leader of the human resistance? Were military officers and prominent figures going to listen to this prophet and say let’s put this guy in charge. False. (Even though an alternate version of the script had this element). Just because the bombs have dropped doesn’t mean John Connor is the leader of humanity. The movie takes place in 2019, a full 10 years before the very first Terminator is sent back into time. John Connor has ten years to fulfill his destiny.
So why is he a top priority even in 2019? And more importantly, why is Kyle Reese (John’s father) number one on the hit list before John? Kyle is a mere teenager in the movie and will not go forward in time for another ten years. How does SkyNet know about his importance? While never explicitly stated, its safe to assume that one of the Terminators sent back into time at some point interfaced with a SkyNet system that made it aware of their future importance. If I came home today to find my future self waiting to give me some important warning about the future, I might listen. (Exhibit A). So yes, while Kyle Reese nor John Connor did not have the significance to be the number 1 and 2 hitlist targets in 2019, its safe to assume that this list represented their future importance just as they did in Terminator 1-3. Now that that’s out of the way.
The gist of the movie revolves around Marcus Wright, a part human part machine that is unique to the series. He struggles to find redemption for his human past, and identity in the present. John Connor too struggles with whether or not to believe Marcus. John looks into his eyes, and knows that Marcus thinks he is human. But John also knows the warnings of his mother, and even knows the events of his death. Or at least a possible death, where he is fooled into trusting a T-800. So can he trust Marcus? (Interesting enough, the character of Marcus resembles a remarkable similarity to Schwarzenegger’s character in Total Recall, with an equivalent outcome).
The movie was mostly plot driven, only really delving into the character of Marcus Wright, and only briefly into John Connor played by Christian Bail, but I didn’t personally see this as a failing. I wouldn’t have objected to a slightly slower pace to explore the world of 2019 a little more than they did. The action scenes were relevant and unforced. I would have preferred to see some more of Bryce Dallas Howard. Her role in the movie was mostly as a placeholder, and I can only hope she has a more important part in the future. Sam Worthington playing Marcus Wright was absolutely the best part of the movie, as even its biggest critics seem to agree. And I could have used some more Common as well, who seemed to play nearly the exact character he played in Wanted.
The biggest complaint I seem to read is that Marcus’ sacrifice at the end of the movie seemed irrelevant. Why self-terminate for a nobody? I don’t know, why did the Terminator in 2 and 3 give its life for John? Again, this just goes back to my assessment of John’s future importance. That people seem to be getting hung up on this fact seems a little odd to me. In my eyes, this movie complements T3 nicely on how John Connor becomes the protector of humanity. Terminator: Salvation is a great addition to the series, and I really hope they continue the time line far enough where we can see John Connor in the role he was destined to play.