This ended up being more than a rant that a review, but whatever.
Before I start my review, let me just preface this by saying no one wants to hear you complaining that the book/comic is better than the movie equivalent. Every time I hear those words coming out of the movie theater, I feel like I’d be justified in beating them unconscious with my empty popcorn bucket. I’ve had to endure several months of this from my comic-loving friends who still have yet to see the movie, but who will nevertheless make sure to let you know how much it sucks compared to the comic.
A movie is a completely different medium than the movie. I always imagine in my mind the first artist who decided to draw the oral stories on the cave of his wall, and think of the other people responding “Pft, the oral story is so much better than the cave drawing.” Consider if you will, my favorite novel ever written, Snowcrash. There is absolutely no way you could translate that story in full to the big screen. Things would get changed, things that fans of the book might consider essential. Would Hero still be a pizza delivery boy for the mafia? Would the plotline between YT and her mom make it into the movie at all? Entire characters would be cut from the film, and this is ok. Why?
For one, investors generally like to make money. Remaining true to the book may appease some of the hard core fans, but in general they want to make a movie that appeals to as wide as an audience as they can. In a movie like Lord of the Rings, staying true to the original material only helps them, because of the vast amount of people who have read them. In a movie like Wanted, where maybe 1% of the viewers will have read the comic, they may be less inclined to stay so close to the source.
Secondly, not everything in a book is possible to translate into a movie. In a book you are not bound by a word limit nor are you bound by imagination. Absolutely anything you can think of can be in a book. In a movie, you are limited by length, and sorry but no matter how technically advanced we get, it will never be a replacement for the imagination. In cases such as these, sticking to the original material could end up creating some very poor scenes and ultimately a very poor movie.
Thirdly, books don’t have an MPAA. The particular scene my friends expressed great disdain for being absent from the movie is where the main character rapes a movie star, and then kills her with a toaster in the bathtub. I won’t lie and say that doesn’t sound amazing, lol, but a scene like that has its price. It comes with protests from woman’s and/or family groups, it has lawyers suing you for corrupting America’s youth, it has a host of implications that extend beyond the artistic. Not everything can or should be done on video. If you want to push the line, do it in print.
There are some other major plot devices that have changed from the comic, but I won’t get into them since I haven’t read the comic and wouldn’t want to speak unintelligently about them. I definitely want to check it out though, despite all the bitching that I’ve heard, the comic does sound pretty cool.
But anyway, back to my review. Any type of movie like this will ultimately be compared to Matrix. I was pleasantly surprised by the action scenes, and did not consider them derivative or copycat at all. As I told my roommate, Wanted is the movie that Shoot Em Up should have been. Great action sequences, but still a very legit story line. The assassins have special abilities such as bending bullets around walls, or jumping from building to building, but it isn’t corny.
It hit especially close to home from the first scenes regarding the main character at his job. I typically resist when ovies/books/commercials/media tell me that working in a cubicle is meaningless and unfulfilled, but for some reason this particular instance hit close to home. The main character’s shedding of the title of office tool is celebrated when he embraces the life of an assassin, even though his father wanted him to have a normal life. Where is the movie that tells me working a 8-5 desk job is ok? As much as I love constantly being told how much of a sin it is to be normal, I’d appreciate a little propoganda once and a while. Big Brother please get on that, ok?
But seriously, go see this movie. I’ll make the bold claim that if you have ever liked any action movie ever, then you’ll enjoy this movie. Unless you’ve read the comic, in which case you’ll probably hate it on principal.
Update: Actually, not every one who read the comic hated the movie. (Potential spoiler warning there).